Well, technically he's not an official "Pilgrim" but he's close. This is about Thomas Pope, our ancestor. It's a story that's revealed by small details in the first-hand accounts of Plymouth Colony. It involves land, taxes, Indians, marriage and children, barrels, corn, beer, disputes, slander, murder. It also involves a property, belonging to Thomas' in-laws, that offers modern-day tours. How great is that? This blog post is not meant to be a full accounting of Thomas' history. Just enough to get you started.
![]() |
| The world in 1630 - showing an unfinished North America |
Thomas Pope, came to America from England around 1632. We don't know why. We don't know which ship he sailed on. We're not sure who he came with. It's estimated that he was born anywhere from 1608 to 1612, which would make him between 20 and 24 years old when he landed in the new world. The Mayflower had arrived only twelve years earlier.
![]() |
| Mayflower Replica - Plymouth |
Below is the only known photo we have of Thomas arriving on the ship. (Well, I tried.)
![]() |
| Robbie Hummel - Mayflower Replica - 1963 |
When Thomas arrived, there were a little more than 300 residents of the Plymouth (also spelled "Plimoth") Plantation. His name first appears in Plymouth in the tax list (of course) of 1633, with a tax of 9 shillings. He was a "cooper," one who makes and repairs wooden barrels or tubs.
From the "Geneology of Thomas Pope and His Descendents":
Of the life of Thomas Pope little is known beyond the brief entries which appear in the records of the town and colony of Plymouth, but these are sufficient to show that he was a man of positive character, and of some consideration in the community...
His name appears in a list, August, 1634, entitled, "The names of all the males that are able to beare armes from XVI years old to 60 years wth in the seuerall Toune Shipps."
October 6, 1636, he was granted five acres of land "at the fishing point next Slowly field, and said Thomas be allowed to build."
June 7, 1637, we find his name among the list of persons who volunteered to go under "Mr. Prence" on an expedition against the Pequots.
The Pequots were, as you might imagine, less than thrilled that their lands were being encroached on by the colonists. It was no surprise that eventually war broke out, with the Pequots facing an alliance of the Plymouth, Massachusettes Bay, and Saybrook Colonies along with the Naragansett and Mohegan tribes. The war lasted 4 years. The Pequot lost. Many hundreds of Pequot died and hundreds were sold into slavery.
Below is a diagram of one of the battles - an attack on a Pequot fort at Mystic (now Connecticut), on July 13, 1637. Of the estimated 600 people in the village, only seven survived to be taken prisoner, and seven escaped. Then the village was set on fire. All within an hour.
The war was pretty much the end of the tribe. Even their name was taken away from them. A treaty was signed in which:
The Pequots were then bound by COVENANT, That none should inhabit their native Country, nor should any of them be called PEQUOTS any more, but MOHEAGS and NARRAGANSETTS for ever.
The Pequots were then bound by COVENANT, That none should inhabit their native Country, nor should any of them be called PEQUOTS any more, but MOHEAGS and NARRAGANSETTS for ever.
When he returned from the Pequot expedition, Thomas Pope married Anne Fallowell "before the Govrnor" [William Bradford] in Plymouth on July 28, 1637. (NOTE: the spellings of names and everything else was pretty wobbly in those times, so bear with me.) Anne's father was Gabriel Fallowell and her mother was Catherine Finney (or Phinney), both living in Plymouth.
![]() |
| Governor William Bradford's history, "Of Plimoth Plantation" |
Thomas and Anne's daughter, Hannah, was born around 1639, and it is believed that Anne died shortly thereafter.
From the "Geneology of Thomas Pope and His Descendents":
[Thomas] sold his property at the fishing point to John Bonham, August 28, 1640, perhaps on account of the death of his wife, the precise date of which event is unknown.
November 2, 1640, he was granted "5 acres of meadowing in South Meadows toward Gavans Colebrook meadows."
On May 29, 1646 Thomas married Sarah Jenney. Sara's father (then deceased) was John Jenney who had come to Plymouth with his wife, Sarah Carey, and two children in 1623. John and Sarah were originally from England but moved to Leiden, Holland, as part of the Separatist movement, in a search for religious freedom. They then sailed to America on the ship, "Little James." A son was born on the ship. Daughter Sarah was born two years later in Plymouth.
Here's an excerpt from a letter written by Emmanuel Altham, a visitor to the Plymouth Plantation, September, 1623 [emphasis added]:
After our arrival in New England, we found all our plantation in good health, and neither man, woman or child sick. And here, likewise, we found the other ship set forth by the Company, who came from Portsmouth six days after us, and arrived here at New England ten days before, with all her people well - as we with our people did the like, and yet one good wife Jennings was brought abed of a son aboard our ship and was very well.
NOTE: As an example of the challenges of the variable spelling of the time period, I offer the following description of the betrothal and marriage of John Jenney and Sarah Carey in Leiden:
Jene, Jehan of Norwich in England, Brewer’s mate, living in Rotterdam, acc by Rogier Wilson his acq betr 5 Sept. 1614, mar 1 Nov. 1614 to Sara Kaire of Monksoon in England, acc by Johanna Leyns her acq
John was a brewer and miller. He was described as:
a godly, though otherwise a plain man, yet singular for publicness of spirit, setting himself to seek and promote the common good of the plantation of new Plimouth.
In 1626, Jenney helped with the refinancing of the Plantation. He also served several terms as an Assistant to the Governor. However, John Jenney's lasting legacy is his corn mill. In 1636 he was authorized to:
...erect a mill for grinding and beating of corn upon the brook of Plymouth.
The first settlers tried to find water on Cape Cod. But they gave up, finding instead further north "a very sweet brook," which they (imaginatively) called "Town Brook." The brook was fed by springs of "as good water as can be drunk." It was close to the marsh, which made it easy for them to anchor their boats. Town Brook became the main water supply for the Pilgrims.
![]() |
| Jenney Grist Mill - reconstructed |
Prior to the mill, the Pilgrims would grind their corn using a mortar and pestle, as they'd been taught by the Patuxet people. This laborious process, however, was not going to work for a growing colony. So the mill allowed the Pilgrims to use the power of the brook to grind a great quantity of corn in a short period of time. And thus singlehandedly bringing to an end the mortar and pestle industry :)
The waters of Town Brook turn two 2,500-pound grooved stone wheels, which, in turn, grind the corn. If you want more detail than that, you'll have to go on a tour... with this guy (below).
![]() |
| The Jenney grindstone |
The Jenney Mill guide says that industry and capitalism began here. John Jenney was the first person paid for services in the United States, and this mill is considered America’s first manufacturing facility.
When John died in 1644, it is recorded that his wife, Sarah, promised to run the mill:
Mris Jenney, upon the psentment agst her, pmiseth to amend the grinding at the mill, and to keepe the morters cleane, and baggs of corne from spoyleing and looseing.
In truth, day-to-day operations were most likely run by one or more of their sons. The mill operated continuously for over two hundred years. It burned down in 1847 and was reconstructed in the 1970's. It is open for tours, as is the Jenney home. And they serve ice cream. And beer.
![]() |
| John Jenney House |
Above is the John Jenney house. If you believe the enthusiastic pitch of the Jenney Mill's owners, Jenney had a malting floor and kiln here, and thus it was the site of the "first microbrewery in America."
So, it looks like the Pope clan (or at least the Pope clan's in-laws) can be considered responsible for the birth of manufacturing, entrepreneurship, and beer in America. Go, Popes!
Over the next seventeen years, Thomas and Sarah had seven children. Their second-born, Seth, is our ancestor. (More about Seth, as well as his sister Susanna and brother John in another blog post.)
Susanna - born c. 1647
Seth - January 13, 1648 or 1649
Thomas - March 25, 1651
John - March 15, 1652 or 1653
Sarah - c. 1656
Joanna - c. 1658
Isaac - 1664
In 1648, Thomas served on a committee to investigate a murder. The account of Alice Bishop's killing of her four year old daughter is particularly gruesomely detailed. Here is what the committee reported [emphasis added]:
These sheweth, that on July the
22cond, 1648, wee, whose names are vnderwritten, were sworne by Mr Bradford,
Gouerner, to make inquiry of the death of the child of Allis Bishop, the wife
of Richard Bishope. Wee declare, yt coming into the house of the said Richard
Bishope, we saw at the foot of a ladder wh leadeth into an vpper chamber, much
blood; and going vp all of us into the chamber, wee found a woman child, of
about foure yeares of age, lying in her shifte vppon her left cheeke, with her
throat cut and the said Allis hath confessed to fiue of vs att one time, yt
shee murdered the child with the said knife.
[signed] John Howland, James Hurst,
Robert Lee, John Shawe, Francis Cooke, John Cooke, James Cole, Gyells Rickard,
Richard Sparrow, THOMAS POPE, Francis Billington, William Nelson.
Alice Bishop was hanged on October 4th of the same year. It is thought that this was the fifth hanging in Plymouth Colony, and the first of a woman there. It's likely that most people in the colony witnessed her execution.
In June 1651 Thomas was chosen surveyor of highways.
Starting in 1647 and continuing off and on over the next twenty plus years, Thomas had some run-ins with his neighbors and with the law:
June 1, 1647 - an action for slander was brought against Thomas Pope, confessed, authors and defendants were brought in equally guilty, and damages paid.
June 5, 1656 - Thomas Pope was listed as a "quarrelsome trespasser" by John Barnes in "Barnes vs. Thomas Pope and Samuel Jenney."
1659 - Thomas Lettice brought charges against Thomas Pope for abusive "carriages" at the mill at Plymouth, and Pope was fined ten shillings to the use of the colony. [NOTE: a "carriage" has something to do with an assault, as far as I can tell.]
December, 1663 - Thomas Pope and Gyles Rickard, Senirt, were arrested "for breaking the King's peace by striking each other, and were fined each three shillings and four pence;" and "said Pope, his striking of said Rickard's wife, and for other turbulent carriages, in word and deed, the Court have centenanced him to find sureties for his good behavior."
February 7, 1664, and also May 2, 1665 - Thomas quarreled with one John Barnes about a boundary.
May 1665 - Further complaints by Barnes against Thomas Pope for trespass.
May 1665 - Pope accused Barnes for violent opposition to his (Pope's) children, and for striking one of the children.
October 4, 1665 - Another land boundary dispute, "Barnes against Thomas Pope" and "Pope against Gyles Rickard," "to be settled by Court appointed surveyors Lt. Morton
and George Bonum."
June 7, 1670 - Thomas Pope was "fined 10 shillings for vilifying the ministry."
1668 he is recorded as having taken the "Freeman's Oath," which is a fascinating loyalty oath with delightfully Puritan language:
I _____ being by Gods providence, an Inhabitant, and Freeman, within the jurisdiction of this Commonwealth; do freely acknowledge my self to be subject to the Government thereof: And therefore do here swear by the great and dreadful Name of the Ever-living God, that I will be true and faithfull to the same, and will accordingly yield assistance & support thereunto, with my person and estate, as in equity I am bound; and will also truly endeavor to maintain and preserve all the liberties and priviledges thereof, submitting my self to the wholesome Lawes & Orders made and established by the same. And further, that I will not plot or practice any and reveal the same to lawfull Authority now here established, for the speedy preventing thereof. Moreover, I doe solemnly bind my self in the sight of God, that when I shal be called to give my voyce touching any matter of this State, in which Freemen are to deal, I will give my vote and suffrage as I shall judge in mine own conscience may best conduce and tend to the publike weal of the body, So help me God in the Lord Jesus Christ.
![]() |
| Plymouth Plantation |
Maybe it was the land disputes, personal disputes, or disputes with the ministry. We'll never know. But something caused Thomas Pope to want to leave Plymouth. In 1673 he was granted land on the east side of the Acushnet River at Dartmouth. It was said that it was a purchase from the Indians, however it appears that the land had previously been purchased by William Bradford and Miles Standish twenty years before. It's likely that Thomas acquired one of the shares of the Bradford/Standish land. He was over 60 years old. He moved to Dartmouth with his wife Sarah and their children. His daughter, Hannah, from his first marriage, stayed in Plymouth.
I'll end this post with the inventory of the belongings of Katheren Fallowell, the mother of Thomas Popes first wife, Anne. The inventory is from her will of 1673. I think it gives us a small window into the sparse simplicity of life in Plymouth Colony.
The Inventory of Katheren Fallowell
An Inventory of the Goods of the widdow Fallowell taken by vs Robert Finney; and Thomas Cushman
Item 1 bed and bolster
Item 2 pillowes 2 blanketts
Item 1 Couerlid and a paire of sheets
Item a paire of Curtaines
Item 2 pillow beers
Item 1 Sew homspon Coate plaine
Item 3 Coates 1 paire of bodies
Item 1 mohear Coate and a Carsey wastcoate
Item 1 stuffe Coate and a Cersey wastcoate
Item 2 Cloth Coates and a Cloth wastcoate
Item 1 Cloake and a hatt and a Green Apron
Item 6 old shifts 3 quoyffs 6 Crosclothes and 1 dressing;
Item 2 Cowes a sheep and a yeerling Lamb
Item 3 pound and 17s in mony
Mr Thomas Cushman and Robert Finney made oath to this writing on each sydes therof viz that this is a true Inventory of such parte of the estate of Gabriell Fallowell which Katheren Fallowell; by his will was ordered to dispose off; and likewise; of her owne proper estate;
Taken before mee Constant Southworth Asistant;
The 7th day of June Anno: domine 1673.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
To link to a rather poorly-produced yet mildly-informative little video about the John Jenney Mill, CLICK HERE.
















































































